Q: "If the world depends on you, and you die, and it thus ceases to exist, does it have any reality in any substantial sense? No.
One might say, 'But if I die, it is still an actuality for others.' No. It is still an unreality, in that it depends on the perceiver or sensor. If a plague killed every thing on earth, who or what would there be to say that there was a world in any respect?" [from "Present Right Now," p. 187, Living Nonduality]
Can [you] elaborate on that, please? I'd appreciate it if you could explain why it wouldn't exist even if there was no one there to perceive it?
A: The word nothing actually means "no thing; nonexistent; void of meaning." A thing is "an entity, distinguishable from all others." What creates the difference between one thing and another thing is the definition which we have assigned to each: "it is this, because it is not that." We conclude that each defined thing, having a "meaning," exists; a separate form, construction, concept or entity thus distinguishable from other things which we deem to exist. It is by this conscious intellectual process that each thing is invested with reality by us. (In fact, the word real is derivative of the Latin word res, which means "thing.")
We have a word that defines "the totality of all things that exist": universe. In other words, all of the things which we can cognitively define is what comprises the universe. Although our world is not separate from the universe, we have an exclusive distinction for it: this particular planet and every thing that accompanies it. So, the universe, world and all else "exist" as such because our cognized locutions have defined their "reality."
If our defining minds had never made their appearance, what could be said to be real? Well, no thing. Without at least one capable mind to define what is "real," existent, as contrasted to what is "unreal," or nonexistent, such designations as real or unreal have no relevance when applied to the universe (or anything it contains). In fact, the universe does not exist itself as any conceivable thing, in the absence of a mind to specially identify it.
So, from this standpoint, the world is not real, no matter how many minds conceive it to be so. The world is dependent upon our conception of it. No one to determine so, no "world" that "exists."
Viewing the World
by Robert Wolfe on August 14th, 2011
Posted in Living Nonduality, Selections, Questions Tagged with real, unreal, existence, nonexistence, world, things, universe, reality
0 Comments
Leave a Comment
Search
Categories
Advaita (6)
Audio (4)
Books (10)
Christianity (3)
Dialogue (4)
Gospel of Thomas (2)
Interview (8)
Link (4)
Living Nonduality (77)
Meeting (5)
Monograph (33)
Nondual Teachers (16)
Questions (28)
Recording (10)
Selections (9)
Unpublished (10)
Video (9)
Tags
Absolute Actions Adyashanti Alan Watts Awakening Awaken Awareness Bell Bible Bohm Brain Buddha Buddhism Consciousness Continuity Copernicus Cosmology David Bohm David Godman Death Deep sleep Deepak Chopra Doer Dzogchen Einstein Enlightenment Essence Experience Galileo Genesis Gisin Godwin God Hafiz Herbert Intelligence I Jesus John Sherman Karma Krishnamurti Lao-Tsu Malin Meister Eckhart Mind Nature Nisargadatta Nonduality Observer Oneness Quantum Physics Ramana Maharshi Ramana Rumi Satsang Scientists Self-realization Shankara Siddhartha Smolin Stapp Subject-Object Tao Thomas Thoughts Thought Tolle Vedas Witness Words Zen Zukav advaita ajnani animate appearance attachment author awakened awake balance beingness being belief benevolent benigh body books book boundary character cling compassion conflict confusion connected creation destiny dharma disciple discussion disillusionment divine division doing dualism dualistic duality ego emptiness enlightened eternal existence eye fate fear force forgiveness formlessness formless forms freedom future gospel grace group guru harmony here and now here holy idealism idealization ideal idea identity ideology illusion impermanence impermanent impersonal improvement inanimate inclusion infinite insight interconnectedness interconnected interconnection interview intuition jnani judgement judgment life love manifest masters meditation meeting menos me negative neutrino new release new testament no thing nonattachment nondual teachers nondual nonexistence nonlocality nothingness nothing now observed omnipresent organism origin outside the box overholt parable pathless path permanent physical physics poem positive possessions practice predetermination presence present quantum mechanics quantum quiet mind radical radio ratiocination reality realization real recording relationship relative renunciation saint science scripture seeing seeker seeking self-interest self-realized self separate separation should be simple simplicity sleep some thing something source space spirituality spiritual spirit states state stillness suffering sutras tat tvam asi teachers teachings things time title totality transformation truth ultimate reality ultimate unchanging unity universal universe unreal vedanta video void what is whole wisdom wizard wolfe world
0


